In Memoriam: The Penny, the Blue Folder, and the Lost Art of Pocket Treasure

The penny is officially dead. Last year, the Mint finally pulled the plug after the cost of stamping out a single one-cent piece crept toward four cents—an economic model that would make even a mediocre lemonade stand file for bankruptcy—and President Trump has now signed the formal death notice. Most of the country greeted the news with a collective shrug, or perhaps a quiet sigh of relief that there will be one fewer piece of copper-plated shrapnel rattling around the cup holder.
I took it a little harder.

Because long before I was a physician, or a grandfather, or a guy trying to keep his handicap respectable, I was a preteen in Whitestone, Queens, with a serious numismatic habit and a standing appointment at the local Chase bank.

My routine was a study in high-stakes finance. I would walk up to the teller window, slide a crisp fifty-cent piece or a couple of quarters across the marble counter, and ask for a roll of pennies. The teller would hand back a tight, heavy paper cylinder containing fifty Lincoln cents. To an adult, it was fifty cents. To me, it was a treasure chest—a sealed mystery novel waiting to be cracked open on my bedroom desk.

Waiting right beside it was my prized possession: a tri-fold blue Whitman coin folder, its cardboard pages punched with neat little circular slots stretching all the way back to 1909, the year the first Lincoln penny was struck. Every slot was a tiny void demanding to be filled, and my thumb got a serious workout pressing each newly discovered year and mint mark firmly into place.

Every kid with a blue folder knew the Holy Grail. It sat right there on the first page, mocking you with its empty cardboard circle: the 1909-S VDB. Minted in San Francisco in tiny numbers, bearing the initials of designer Victor D. Brenner on the reverse before the Mint got squeamish about the artist signing his own work, it was the Mona Lisa of pocket change. Did I ever find a 1909-S VDB in a Chase bank roll in Whitestone? Of course not. That would have been like pulling a Honus Wagner out of a pack of bubble gum.

I did, however, pull its Philadelphia cousin—the 1909 VDB—straight out of a paper roll. Less valuable, sure, but to a twelve-year-old squinting under a desk lamp, it might as well have been a doubloon from a sunken Spanish galleon. I stared at those three tiny letters at the bottom of the wheat stalks as if I had just cracked the Dead Sea Scrolls.

Naturally, no self-respecting collector stops at cents. Soon I expanded my empire to nickels, dimes, and quarters—though quarters required a much more aggressive capital-raising strategy, funded almost entirely by my allowance and the sweat equity of mowing neighbors’ lawns. Suddenly my desk was a miniature museum of American design: worn Buffalo nickels whose dates had half-vanished into pocket lint, graceful Winged Liberty dimes giving way to the crisp profile of FDR, and Washington quarters with that fierce, outstretched eagle anchoring the reverse.

What really hooked me, though, were the oddballs—the glorious glitches and bureaucratic detours of the U.S. Mint. I was fascinated by the ghostly 1943 wartime pennies, struck in zinc-coated steel instead of copper so the metal could go toward the war effort. I hunted tirelessly for the legendary 1955 doubled die cent, the product of an over-exuberant press that stamped the date and lettering twice, slightly off-kilter, turning a factory blunder into a collector’s fortune.

And then there was my favorite historical curiosity: an 1870s three-cent piece, a tiny, short-lived relic of post-Civil War currency policy. I would have paid good money just to sit in the gallery during that congressional hearing. “Wait a minute, Senator—let me make sure I have this straight. We have a one-cent piece, and we have a five-cent piece, and nobody thought to make a three-cent piece? What an unconscionable omission! Someone call the Mint immediately.” You almost have to admire the sheer legislative optimism of a country that looked at basic arithmetic and decided the gap between one and five was simply too wide to bear.

As I got a little older and my liquid assets improved, my tastes grew more refined. I graduated to Proof Sets—pristine, uncirculated coinage sealed hermetically in plastic, untouched by human hands, free of a single circulation blemish. And at the absolute summit sat the silver dollars, heavy and gleaming, with Lady Liberty in all her glory. To this day, my earliest memory of Las Vegas has nothing to do with blackjack tables or neon lights. It is the staggering, clinking abundance of silver dollars—not as gambling chips, mind you, but as a numismatist’s fever dream. (Gold coins, alas, were firmly outside my economic bracket, though I spent plenty of happy hours paging through price guides and opining on rarities I had roughly the same chance of owning as the Hope Diamond.)

Eventually, life intervened. Years passed, households packed up and moved, and somewhere along the way most of those blue folders and sealed sets vanished into the great Bermuda Triangle of childhood treasures—gone the same heartbreaking way as my Mickey Mantle Topps cards. (If there is an attic in the afterlife, I expect to find a shoebox containing a 1952 Mantle, a few dozen Whitman folders, and a very smug angel refusing to trade.)

So yes, I can accept the cold math that killed the penny. Nobody wants the Treasury spending four cents to manufacture one. Still, I find myself mourning more than a defunct piece of legal tender. I feel a genuine pang for the kids growing up today, thoroughly bamboozled by the frictionless magic of digital money—tapping watches, swiping plastic, watching numbers flicker across a screen. Money used to have weight. It had edges, dates, history, and the faint metallic smell of a hundred hands it had passed through before reaching yours.

A penny doesn’t buy much anymore, of course. For a long time, it hasn’t bought anything at all. But once upon a time in Whitestone, fifty of them wrapped in a paper tube could buy a kid an entire afternoon of wonder—and the slim, glorious chance that the very next coin you flipped over might just be a 1909-S VDB.

Rest in peace, Abe. You were worth a lot more than a cent.